Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop in Dover

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop in Dover
4 / 5
50 reviews

110 W 4td St, Dover, OH 44622-2936, Dover

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Does Mary Zifer's's deliver?

No

Do they serve single slices?

Try the rigatoni with meat sauce

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
HO
Harry Ogletree
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Excellent, great pizza and service

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
bb
bob brinker
google
11.23.2018
3/5

Ok pizza. Something different

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
CA
Cindy Alesiano
google
11.19.2018
5/5

We have been eating here for over 40 years! Great food when dining in, a d carry out too! One of our fav pizzas and salads@

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
JR
Jonathan Rennicker
google
10.25.2018
5/5

Family owned business, lots of character

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
mh
maleatha hall
google
10.17.2018
5/5

It's our favorite place to get pizza!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
SW
Steve Wilson
google
10.11.2018
3/5

The crust, cheese, and sauce were good, but the green peppers and mushrooms seemed to come from a can and were a little unappetizing. I prefer fresh ingredients. Also, I wasn't crazy about the sausage.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
JS
Jeff Smith
google
10.01.2018
5/5

Great service.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
Rh
Rick haley
google
09.18.2018
5/5

Only the best pizza you can buy. Just fantastic. Crust is amazing cheese is unique, pepperoni is perfect. Never in Dover without eating at least 1 pizza.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
HS
Harleyquinn Smith
google
09.13.2018
5/5

Absolute favorite ❤️ place to eat, the pasta is great, bread is great, friendly atmosphere

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
js
jordan schlabach
google
09.05.2018
5/5

Hands down the best pizza you will ever experience. 100% must Stop! first place i go when i hit dover!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
NF
Nathan Fensler
google
08.18.2018
5/5

Not quiet like I remember back in the day. Thanks for a good meal!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
tj
teri jones
google
07.13.2018
5/5

Thank you for great Food & Service!!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
AK
Anthany Krebs
google
06.17.2018
5/5

Best pizza place in town

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
CS
Christine Sergent
google
06.15.2018
4/5

Yummy brownies

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
CK
Claire Kandle
google
06.07.2018
4/5

Love the homemade pizza sauce and salad dressing.Staff is always friendly.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
MB
Micah Bell
google
06.02.2018
5/5

I've been a fan of this food for a very long time. The only real complaint is the prices. It's good pizza and I drive 30 mile once in awhile one way but damn...30 dollars for 2 pizzas?

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
SS
Steve Shumaker
google
04.19.2018
5/5

Another of Tuscarawas County's great pizza shops! Aways a great thick crust pizza!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
sa
stardustearth always
google
03.01.2018
5/5

Always a treat. Everything is good

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
DR
Dave Rose
google
11.04.2017
1/5

Quit going to New Phila Mary Ziffers because they could not make pizzas as ordered. Last two from Dover Mary Ziffers have been terrible. This one toppings burnt and dough not baked. One before was so over baked that pepperonis had burnt taste. Guess I’ll try Penso’s since neither Ziffers shop seem to care.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
JM
Joe Mccartney
google
10.25.2017
4/5

Very good spaghetti and pizza

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
SH
Sooner Hart
google
10.17.2017
5/5

Great hometown pizza shop. Love to go there for lunch!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
BD
Brittany Dodson
google
08.06.2017
5/5

We loved our pizza great home town place to eat!!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
ThaBiGGDoGG
google
07.03.2017
5/5

Pizza tasted really good.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
LM
Linda Marner
google
06.13.2017
3/5

pizza is good but it needs more sauce on it n there were hardly any green peppers n skimpy on pepperonis STILL miss grandma zifers WAS TH BEST!!!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
CW
Christina Wigfield
google
04.24.2017
3/5

Pizza was good but it was undercooked. Crust was doughy. Salad and Cannoli were very good. Still like the New Phila location better.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
FP
Flower Power
google
04.20.2017
1/5

I don't know who is making the pizza but I ordered a personal and it was so hard it broke my tooth, and the cheese was tough I couldn't chew it, tasted nothing like I remember. I am very dissatisfied with the pizza now will not be eating there again.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
LP
Lisa Pulley
google
04.06.2017
3/5

Something is different my pepperoni's were burnt, and the sauce seemed kinda bitter? Not the same as I remember? And the crust was a little hard it made a huge mess of crumbs...Gonna try Phila next time.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
SJ
Shaun Jackson
google
04.01.2017
5/5

Great pizza. Best pizza in town.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
AK
Al K
google
03.07.2017
5/5

Can't go wrong ordering from here. Everything on the menu is outstanding. Homemade goodness for the tummy! YUM!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
VL
Vicky Law
google
02.08.2017
5/5

Emily was an excellent server! Food was great!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
BE
B. Emler
google
01.16.2017
4/5

Great family atmosphere and small town feel. Pizza is excellent and the cannolis are the best around! My only complaint is the limited seating.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
IA
Ivan Anderson
google
01.03.2017
5/5

Best pasta around. Large portions at a very reasonable price

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
cR
christel Rypien
google
11.22.2016
5/5

It's my favorite hometown pizza! Casual dining or carry out. Friendly staff and great pizza.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
DR
David Reed
google
11.19.2016
3/5

They pizza is ok. I didn't feel it was anything great. I also tried a meatball sub. It was ok too. The service was friendly.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
PM
Peggy Miller
google
10.21.2016
5/5

Great eats, and the staff are just as good. Always ready to help no matter what

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
RR
Rich Ross
google
09.20.2016
5/5

I grew up eating Mary Zifer's pizza back in the day when we picked them up at the house. They were awesome. Then I moved to to Houston in 1982. I haven't had a Zifer pizza since then...until today. Although the surroundings may have changed, the pizza is as awesome as ever. Now how can I get them when I go back to Texas?

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
DR
Devin Ross
google
09.04.2016
1/5

Food cold not even made how I asked no point in calling no one does there job right either way

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
PS
Phebe Stull
google
08.21.2016
5/5

Great pizza! Throwback to the old Ziffers! If you grew up on it, you gotta give it a try!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
NK
Nick Kendle
google
07.10.2016
3/5

Very inconsistent. Sometimes the pizza is amazing and other times it is dried up with very little sauce. Make sure to check your toppings before you get home. My toppings have been wrong multiple times. If things were consistent, it would easily be 5 stars.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
GT
Gary Totten
google
06.18.2016
4/5

Service was quick and staff friendly. Just be nice to see wings on menu

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
TN
Trav Nay
google
06.17.2016
3/5

Pretty good, maybe a tad pricey

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
MG
Melanie Gardner
google
06.10.2016
5/5

I brought a bowl of wedding soup home for lunch the next day. It was the best I've ever had!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
BB
B B
google
06.03.2016
2/5

I dont care for cheddar cheese on a pizza, but the staff was very nice, and th place was very clean.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
DA
Daniel Andrella
google
06.03.2016
3/5

Reminded me of store bought frozen pizza. Nothing special with the pizza. Service fine. Place was clean. Cheap eats.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
BL
Bill Linard
google
05.12.2016
1/5

They fix the air conditioning in the food was great as usual now that it's cooled off in the plate in the restaurant

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
KS
Keith Stone
google
03.17.2016
5/5

Mary zifer's pizza is no doubt our go to for a delicious and reasonably priced pizza. Plenty of toppings and always fresh. Their breadsticks are very good also. My wife and I get a small 2 topping pizza and an order of breadsticks with cheese for around $12. We are both full and very pleased with the quality and taste.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
KS
Kris S
google
03.13.2016
5/5

Seriously the best pizza I have ever had!

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
DJ
Debbie Jackson
google
02.13.2016
4/5

Love their spagetti.Good good and good service.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
Ji
J.d. iGrandson.
google
02.05.2016
3/5

Pizzas good 👍 but a little expensive.

Mary Zifer`s Pizza Shop
AB
Arthur Boehme
google
01.27.2016
5/5

Great pizza, great service!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 13303433512

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!